Big Cartel vs Shopify Plus

Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, and integrations.

Quick Verdict

Big Cartel offers more features (30 vs 25) and more integrations (10 vs 3). Starting price: Big Cartel at $15/mo vs Shopify Plus at $399/mo. Big Cartel has 30 unique features while Shopify Plus has 25 unique features, with 0 features in common.

Big CartelShopify Plus
CategoryE-commerceE-commerce
Total Features3025
AI-Powered Features00
Starting Price$15/mo$399/mo
Pricing Tiers32
Integrations103
Shared Features0
Shared Integrations0
Data Quality85%70%

Feature Comparison by Category

Analytics (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Advanced Analytics

Architecture (0 vs 2)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Headless Commerce API
React-based Headless Stack

Automation (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Automated Workflows

B2B (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
B2B Commerce Features

Checkout (0 vs 3)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
High-Performance Checkout
Lightning-fast Checkout
Shop Pay

Commerce (3 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Digital Goods Delivery
In-Person Selling
Physical Goods Selling

Compliance (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Sales Tax Autopilot

Core Platform (0 vs 2)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
All-in-one Platform
Extensible Platform

Data Management (2 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Bulk Product Editing
Product Import

Design (3 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Customizable Templates
Mobile-Friendly Shop Template
Shop Customization

Domain Management (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Custom Domain Support

Fulfillment (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Print on Demand

Integration (0 vs 3)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
API Integrations
App Ecosystem
Flexible Integrations

Integrations (2 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Easy-Install Apps
Zapier Integration

International (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Global Expansion

Inventory Management (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Inventory Tracking

Marketing (6 vs 2)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Abandoned Cart Recovery
Advanced Discount Logic
Discount Codes
Google Shopping Connection
Product Drops
Run Ads
Shopify Audiences
Shopify Functions

Mobile (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Mobile App

Payments (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Payment Processing

Pricing (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
No Transaction Fees

Product Management (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Unlimited SKUs

Reliability (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
99.99% Uptime

Reporting (1 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Detailed Reporting
Sales Reporting

Retail (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Omnichannel Solutions

Sales Channels (0 vs 2)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Multi-Channel Management
Social Commerce

Security (1 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Built-in Security
Password-Protected Products

Shipping (2 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Discounted Shipping Labels
Shipping Management

Social Media (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Social Selling

Store Management (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Customizable Online Store

Support (2 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
Priority Support
Real Human Support

Tools (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelShopify Plus
TCO Calculator

Unique Features

Only in Big Cartel (30)

Digital Goods Delivery
In-Person Selling
Physical Goods Selling
Sales Tax Autopilot
Bulk Product Editing
Product Import
Customizable Templates
Mobile-Friendly Shop Template
Shop Customization
Custom Domain Support
Print on Demand
Easy-Install Apps
Zapier Integration
Inventory Tracking
Abandoned Cart Recovery
Advanced Discount Logic
Discount Codes
Google Shopping Connection
Product Drops
Run Ads

+ 10 more unique features

Only in Shopify Plus (25)

Advanced Analytics
Headless Commerce API
React-based Headless Stack
Automated Workflows
B2B Commerce Features
High-Performance Checkout
Lightning-fast Checkout
Shop Pay
All-in-one Platform
Extensible Platform
API Integrations
App Ecosystem
Flexible Integrations
Global Expansion
Shopify Audiences
Shopify Functions
Unlimited SKUs
99.99% Uptime
Detailed Reporting
Omnichannel Solutions

+ 5 more unique features

Want to build your own alternative to Big Cartel or Shopify Plus?

Analyze it with Reap