Big Cartel vs Gumroad

Side-by-side comparison of features, pricing, and integrations.

Quick Verdict

Big Cartel offers more features (30 vs 25) and more integrations (10 vs 2). Starting price: Big Cartel at $15/mo vs Gumroad at Contact Sales. Big Cartel has 29 unique features while Gumroad has 24 unique features, with 1 features in common.

Big CartelGumroad
CategoryE-commerceE-commerce
Total Features3025
AI-Powered Features00
Starting Price$15/moContact Sales
Pricing Tiers32
Integrations102
Shared Features1
Shared Integrations0
Data Quality85%60%

Feature Comparison by Category

Analytics (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Analytics Dashboard

Audience Building (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Follow Button

Audience Management (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Email List Import/Export

Automation (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Automated Workflows

Commerce (3 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Digital Goods Delivery
In-Person Selling
Physical Goods Selling

Compliance (1 vs 2)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Sales Tax Autopilot
Tax Management
VAT Collection

Core Commerce (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Simple Product Upload

Data Management (2 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Bulk Product Editing
Product Import

Design (3 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Customizable Templates
Mobile-Friendly Shop Template
Shop Customization

Digital Products (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Multiple File Formats

Digital Protection (0 vs 2)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
DRM Protection
License Key Generation

Distribution (0 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Direct Payment Links

Domain Management (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Custom Domain Support

Fulfillment (1 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Instant Product Delivery
Print on Demand

Integrations (2 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Easy-Install Apps
Third-Party Integrations
Zapier Integration

Inventory Management (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Inventory Tracking

Marketing (6 vs 4)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Abandoned Cart Recovery
Advanced Discount Logic
Affiliate Management
Discount Codes
Discount Management
Email Broadcasts
Google Shopping Connection
Product Discovery Marketplace
Product Drops
Run Ads

Mobile (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Mobile App

Payments (1 vs 3)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Multi-Currency Support
Payment Options
Payment Processing
Secure Payment Processing

Pricing (1 vs 1)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
No Transaction Fees
Pay What You Want

Reporting (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Sales Reporting

Security (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Password-Protected Products

Shipping (2 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Discounted Shipping Labels
Shipping Management

Social Media (1 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Social Selling

Storefront (0 vs 2)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Custom Domain Support
Customizable Storefront

Subscriptions (0 vs 2)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Membership Management
Recurring Subscriptions

Support (2 vs 0)

FeatureBig CartelGumroad
Priority Support
Real Human Support

Unique Features

Only in Big Cartel (29)

Digital Goods Delivery
In-Person Selling
Physical Goods Selling
Sales Tax Autopilot
Bulk Product Editing
Product Import
Customizable Templates
Mobile-Friendly Shop Template
Shop Customization
Print on Demand
Easy-Install Apps
Zapier Integration
Inventory Tracking
Abandoned Cart Recovery
Advanced Discount Logic
Discount Codes
Google Shopping Connection
Product Drops
Run Ads
Mobile App

+ 9 more unique features

Only in Gumroad (24)

Analytics Dashboard
Follow Button
Email List Import/Export
Automated Workflows
Tax Management
VAT Collection
Simple Product Upload
Multiple File Formats
DRM Protection
License Key Generation
Direct Payment Links
Instant Product Delivery
Third-Party Integrations
Affiliate Management
Discount Management
Email Broadcasts
Product Discovery Marketplace
Multi-Currency Support
Payment Options
Secure Payment Processing

+ 4 more unique features

Want to build your own alternative to Big Cartel or Gumroad?

Analyze it with Reap